Baird's CMC | A Unique Global Communications Management Consultancy

Global Health Discourse 2023

Tel: +44 (0) 1495 828300
Email: team@bairdscmc.com
  • E-mail
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
Menu
  • Home
    • Sexual and Reproductive Health
    • Stakeholder Mapping & Strategy
    • New Services
    • Qualitative & Policy
    • Communications and Management Consultancy
    • Close
  • About us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Our specialist areas
    • Case studies
      • EDCTP sub-Saharan Africa policy research
      • Emerging Democracies and Green Issues
      • Gauging Attitudes Toward an HIV Vaccine
      • Increasing Immunization Coverage in Central India
      • Close
    • Close
  • Network
    • Network map
    • Associates
      • Michael Acott
      • Ashoek Adhikari
      • Francois Baird
      • Gerhard Butschi
      • Steve Bowers
      • Mark Chataway
      • Lenore Cooney
      • Paul Dillon
      • Marta Dourado
      • Martina Dörmann
      • Dirk Van Eeden
      • Alexandra Fullem
      • Frederick Fussi
      • Ingrid Gavshon MBA
      • Denise Gee
      • Denise Gray-Felder
      • Bert Griesel
      • Aman Gupta
      • Darren Jones
      • Danie Kok
      • Andrzej Kropiwnicki
      • Angelle Kwemo
      • Nikolay Kudryashov
      • Mari Lee
      • Simba Makoni
      • Steve Mallach
      • Terry Mandel
      • Matshidiso Masire
      • Valeria McFarren
      • Hugh McKinney
      • Chris Opperman
      • Ken Rabin
      • Mark Rittenberg
      • Simon Russell
      • Jacob Sesinyi
      • Melinda Shaw
      • Cormac Smith
      • James Snodgrass
      • Hema Viswanathan
      • Mina Volovitch
      • Gillian Waddell
      • Joseph Makwata Wambia
      • Chris Ward
      • Gysbert J Wessels
      • Marion Zibelli
      • Close
    • Senior consultants
      • Simon Hardie
      • Close
    • Close
  • Services
    • New Services
      • Media Training
      • Presentation Skills
      • Staff Engagement
      • Reputation Management
      • Close
    • Services
      • Communications counsel
      • New media strategy
      • Advocacy and coalition building
      • Crisis management
      • Market research
      • Strategic planning
      • Staff training and development
      • Risk management and mitigation
      • Close
    • Close
  • Sectors
    • Vaccine Hesitancy
    • Pharma in top 15 markets
    • Pharma in emerging markets
    • Pharma in underdeveloped markets
    • Pharma headquarters planning teams on market assessment
    • Global Development: Health Issues
    • Global Development: Environmental Issues
    • Health equity and access to care
    • Reproductive health and population
    • Vaccines
    • International Donors
    • Government Relations
    • Political Consulting
    • Telecom Sector
    • Financial Services
    • Close
  • News
  • ShopTalk
  • Get in Touch

How come people in international development haven’t noticed the age of austerity?

Portugal is poised for a general strike to protest the austerity measures. Athens is cleaning up. British civil servants have been told that they can’t travel first class on the railways even if they use their own money to upgrade because it would send the wrong message. Across Europe (with the perennial exception of France), we are entering an age of austerity.

So far, the British are saying that international development will be insulated from any cuts. The Scandinavians are singing roughly the same tune but the mainstream Conservative Dutch opposition (who may well be at the core of the next government after the election in two weeks) want to halve overseas development assistance (ODA) to about 0.4% of GDP. As usual, the Dutch may be the trendsetters.

The international development community, meanwhile, seems not to have noticed that the world has changed. Business class lounges still resound with earnest conversations about poverty reduction. Look at the website for next month’s Women Deliver conference and you’ll see, “the world’s women and the world entirely, need courageous leadership and vast funding commitments.” The themes of international travel and wanting more money came together in a Global Fund statement last week: “given that many important forums are scheduled to take place at national and international level which will shape the MDG agenda for 2010- 2015, Ministers of Health and the co-hosting partners agreed to join forces to advocate for increased political and financial support for the health related MDGs.” Search for the word “austerity” on the GAVI vaccine web site and there are two results: one in a 2008 plan for Laos and another in a plan for Guyana. Search for “austerity” on the site of Bono’s One Campaign and the site will ask you to “make sure all words are spelled correctly” because it can’t find anything.

Confronted with evidence that behaviour change communication (bcc) does nothing much to stop the AIDS epidemic in women in the developing world, blogger Gillian Fletcher attacked “the empiricist paradigm” and said that bcc enabled women, ” to consider other ways of being”. That’s alright then.

The prevailing view seems to be that Europeans, Australians and Americans will watch as their hospitals close and their public services shrink but the business of international development will keep booming. This would be a dangerous delusion at any time but it’s positively psychotic at a time when Dambisa Moyo is seemingly on every news channel talking about aid blighting Africa and William Easterly’s Aid Watch blog is being added to the must-read lists of more and more journalists.

If international development is to survive the double dip, it will need a narrative about help in a time of shortages. Some of it will be the silly trite stuff that every government and fundraising NGO has to say: waste will be cut, efficiencies will be found, paper will be recycled, everyone will wear secondhand underwear. Some of it, though, needs to be serious thinking about priorities and acting on evidence. Behaviour change communication doesn’t work; we’ll stop it. Corruption is undermining aid efficacy in Kenya; the aid will go somewhere else. Malawi would rather spend its time fretting about the evils of sodomy than addressing its people’s poverty; fine, let them but they can fret on their own dime.

Developing the narrative will be painful and controversial but if the international development community doesn’t do it, the money will disappear. Businesses, unions, interest groups, pensioners’ alliances and hundreds of others are working flat out to ringfence their spending through new initiatives to show that they are ready to be lean, mean and keen. Sadly, back in the business class lounge, they are just drafting another communique on how massive the extra resources need to be.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • More
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)

Related

Filed Under: ShopTalk Tagged With: Development, MDGs

Contact Us

    Your Name (required)

    Your Email (required)

    Subject

    Your Message

    Please enter the letters below and press Send

    captcha

    Latest Blog Posts

    Welcome

    An astonishing decline in child immunisation numbers in Africa amid the rage of COVID-19, yet another victim of the pandemic

    Global Elite are Bored with Health, Just When It’s Getting Really Exciting

    Copyright © 2023 All rights reserved. Sitemap